Rodri’s season-ending blow exposes player fatigue crisis

Manchester City’s season has been dealt a major blow as their star midfielder Rodri is potentially out for the remainder of the campaign following a suspected ACL injury sustained during their clash with Arsenal.

The Spaniard, who has been pivotal to City’s success in recent years, now faces a long recovery, with the club expecting him to be sidelined until at least the middle of next year. Though no official statement has been made yet, the implications of this injury for City and football as a whole are significant.

Rodri’s Importance to City

Rodri is undoubtedly one of Manchester City’s most crucial players and, arguably, one of the best midfielders in world football today. Since joining the club in 2019, the Spaniard has been a mainstay in Pep Guardiola’s squad, rarely missing games due to injury. According to Transfermarkt, before this season, he had only missed five matches due to injury. His influence is evident not just in City’s domestic triumphs but also on the international stage, having played a key role in Spain’s European Championship victory during the summer.

Despite returning from a hamstring injury, sustained in the European Championship final against England, Rodri suffered a knee injury in the game against Arsenal. The club now fears the worst—a torn ACL, which could see him out of action for the better part of a year.

Can City Cope Without Him?

Manchester City’s reliance on Rodri cannot be overstated. Last season, City lost three out of the four Premier League matches in which Rodri did not feature. While this season started off more positively, with City winning their first four games even without him, playing without Rodri for an extended period is an entirely different challenge. His ability to shield the backline, dictate play from deep, and break up opposition attacks is unmatched in the squad.

City’s transfer dealings have also come into focus. Some argue that they should have done more in the summer transfer window to bring in a direct replacement or backup for Rodri. Although the club considered players like Bruno Guimaraes, no deal materialised. Instead, City brought back Ilkay Gundogan from Barcelona, a player who can fill the midfield but does not provide the same level of defensive solidity.

Mateo Kovacic has been another option, and while he has done reasonably well, his lapses in defensive positioning have been noticeable, especially given the high bar set by Rodri. City have historically adapted to injuries in various positions, such as when Aymeric Laporte’s early-season injury led Guardiola to reshuffle his team. However, coping without Rodri for the majority of the season will be one of their toughest tests.

A Broader Issue: Too Much Football?

Rodri’s injury has raised important questions about the toll modern football takes on players. Last week, Rodri publicly voiced concerns about the relentless schedule, even hinting at the possibility of players striking due to the demands placed on their bodies. His sentiments were echoed by other top football figures, including Real Madrid goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois and Chelsea head coach Enzo Maresca.

Footballers are playing more games than ever, with the expanded Club World Cup, Champions League, and international tournaments all piling onto already packed domestic calendars. For elite players like Rodri, this can mean playing close to 85 matches in a season, leaving little time for rest and recovery.

The workload players face is undeniably linked to injuries, and Rodri’s case could be seen as an example of this. Already moderately injured from a hamstring problem earlier in the season, it is conceivable that the continuous strain on his body contributed to this more serious injury. However, without access to personalised data from Manchester City, it’s impossible to definitively link his injury to workload.

The Response from Football Authorities

While players and coaches have been vocal about the need for fewer matches, football’s governing bodies appear resistant to change. UEFA President Aleksander Ceferin has famously said that if players play fewer games, they will earn less money, a notion that has frustrated many within the football community. FIFA, on the other hand, claims that player health is a priority, yet continues to expand competitions like the World Cup and Club World Cup.

The tension between the desire for more games to increase revenue and the need to protect players’ well-being has been growing in recent years. For top clubs like Manchester City, who could end up playing 75 games this season if they reach the final in all competitions, the risks of injury are ever-present.

What Next for City?For City, the question now is how they will navigate the season without their midfield anchor. The club has options: they could continue to use Gundogan and Kovacic in midfield, possibly supported by youngster Rico Lewis, who may now have the opportunity to prove his worth. Guardiola has been adept at reinventing his teams in the face of adversity, as shown when City won the league without a proper striker or played without a recognised left-back for years. However, the absence of a player as integral as Rodri may push this adaptability to its limits.

City have always managed to stay competitive despite injuries to key players like Kevin De Bruyne and Vincent Kompany in the past. This resilience will be tested once more. If City are to retain their Premier League crown and challenge for European honours, they will need to find new ways of playing without their defensive lynchpin.

A Bigger Conversation About Player Welfare

Rodri’s injury has highlighted the wider issue of player welfare in football. With growing calls for reform, it remains to be seen whether football’s authorities will heed these concerns or continue to prioritise financial gain over the health of the players. In the meantime, Rodri’s absence will be felt not just by City, but by the football community as a whole, as it sparks further debate about the future of the sport and its sustainability in the face of an ever-expanding calendar.